SEO for Beginners
Learn from the SEO Strategist who has 75+ first page Google rankings under her belt.
We’re marketing nerds and business strategists that have generated millions of dollars in client revenue. We're sharing the systems and strategies to help your growing business with marketing that actually converts.
We're Tiffany + Tabatha
How We Ranked a Psychiatry Practice for One of the World’s Most Expensive Keywords—With a Website That Didn’t Even Exist Six Months Earlier
Location: New York City, Financial District
Specialty: Treatment-Resistant Depression & Ketamine Infusion Therapy
Target Keyword: “Psychiatrist in New York City”
Keyword Value: $500-$1,000 per click
Competition Level: Extreme
The Challenge
In May 2020, Dr. Jeff Ditzell contacted us with a problem most SEO agencies would refuse to touch: He was moving his psychiatry practice to NYC’s Financial District and needed to rank for “psychiatrist in New York City”—one of the most competitive, expensive search terms in existence.
The obstacles were staggering:
- Brand-new domain (jeffditzellpsychiatry.com registered June 2020)
- Zero existing online presence (his previous agency kept the website he’d paid for)
- No brand identity beyond a name
- Fewer than 300 social followers
- Google Sandbox effect (new domains typically take 6-12 months just to start ranking)
- Ultra-competitive market (competing against established practices with million-dollar marketing budgets)
Most SEO experts would’ve said it was impossible. That ranking a brand-new domain in NYC healthcare was a fool’s errand. That he’d need to wait 6-12 months just to get out of the Google penalty box.
We said let’s do it.
The Strategy
We didn’t have the luxury of an established domain authority or years of backlinks. What we did have was a methodical SEO approach that prioritized speed without cutting corners.
Phase 1: Foundation (Months 1-3)
Website Architecture
- 30+ page custom website built from scratch
- HIPAA-compliant forms and patient resources
- Mobile-optimized, fast-loading infrastructure
- Clean URL structure designed for SEO from day one
Technical SEO
- Schema markup for local medical practice
- Complete technical audit and implementation
- Site speed optimization (under 2-second load times)
- XML sitemap and robots.txt optimization
- Google Search Console and Analytics setup
Content Strategy
- 4-6 in-depth blog posts per month (1,500+ words each)
- Each post targeted specific long-tail keywords
- Topics aligned with patient search intent (not just medical jargon)
- Internal linking structure to distribute link equity
Local SEO
- Google My Business optimization
- NAP (Name, Address, Phone) consistency across 50+ directories
- Local citation building with healthcare-specific directories
- Geotagged images throughout the site
Link Building
- Securing high-quality backlinks from relevant sources
- Focus on Domain Authority 30+ sites
- Medical directories, healthcare blogs, NYC business listings
- Strategic PR outreach for natural link acquisition
The Timeline
Month 1 (June 2020): Domain registered, website build begins, first blog posts published
Month 2 (July 2020): Website launches, aggressive content production ramps up (4-6 posts/month)
Month 3 (August 2020): Backlink building accelerates, local SEO implementation complete
Month 4 (September 2020): First rankings appear—page 5-7 for target keywords
Month 5 (October 2020): Climbing to page 3-4, organic traffic increasing
Month 6 (December 2020): 🎯 BREAKTHROUGH: Top 10 ranking for “psychiatrist NYC”
By 6 months from zero, we had a brand-new domain ranking on page one.
The Results
SEO Performance:
Top 10 ranking for “psychiatrist in New York City” in 6 months
75+ first-page rankings achieved across target keywords
+162% increase in website users from organic search
+172% increase in sessions year-over-year
Practice fully booked from organic traffic within 8 months
Business Impact:
60-70% of new patients came from organic search (not social, not ads, not referrals)
Rates increased by 2.5x with patient demand remaining strong
Rankings lasted (still performing months after engagement ended—proof of quality)
The keyword “psychiatrist in New York City” is worth $500-$1,000 per click in paid advertising. We achieved that visibility organically, with a domain that was brand-new.
Why This Was “Impossible”
Let’s be clear about what we accomplished:
1. New Domain Penalty
Google typically sandboxes new domains for 6-12 months, making it nearly impossible to rank during that window. We beat the sandbox in 6 months.
2. Ultra-Competitive Market
NYC psychiatry is one of the most competitive healthcare niches in the world. We were competing against practices with:
- Established domains (10-20 years old)
- Massive backlink profiles (thousands of links)
- Multi-million dollar marketing budgets
- Teams of SEO specialists
3. High-Value Keywords
“Psychiatrist NYC” commands $500-$1,000 per click in Google Ads. That level of competition means established players fight hard to maintain their rankings.
4. Healthcare Sector Challenges
Medical SEO has extra scrutiny (Google’s YMYL—Your Money Your Life standards), requiring exceptional E-E-A-T (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, Trustworthiness) signals.
And we did it with a domain that was six months old.
We Proved It Wasn’t a Fluke
In 2024, we repeated this success with a facial plastic surgeon in Newport Beach, California—another ultra-competitive, high-value market.
Same approach. Same results.
- Brand-new website domain
- Ultra-competitive plastic surgery market
- First-page rankings achieved in 4 months
- 590 new organic users in 90 days
- Multiple competitive keywords ranking in top 10 positions
Two of the hardest markets in the country. Two brand-new domains. Both achieved “impossible” results.
The Expansion
What started as an SEO project evolved into a full-service marketing partnership over four years:
Authority Building (Years 2-4)
- Launched podcast “Psychs & The City” (produced, edited, published weekly)
- Secured top-tier PR features: Forbes, The New York Times, Business Insider, Psychology Today
- Grew social media from 300 to 10,000+ followers
- Email list grew to 12,658+ subscribers
- Created branded video content and office tour materials
Business Operations
- Fractional CMO services (comprehensive marketing strategy)
- Fractional COO support (operations, HR, systems)
- Full rebrand tied to office relocation
- Scalable systems for practice expansion
Dr. Jeff Ditzell started out as a psychiatrist with no website to one of the most visible mental health voices in New York City.
But it all started with that impossible SEO win in month 6.
Client Testimonial
“The team is amazing, and has been a driving force in our ongoing and consistent growth over the last year (despite being in the midst of a pandemic). From PR to all the nuances of marketing, to a beautiful and innovative website and SEO…Tiffany and Tabatha are results driven and give clear and concise analytics that demonstrate how their efforts directly translate into tremendous results. Top notch team, and very easy to work with, we are happy to give our highest recommendation!”
– Dr. Jeff Ditzell, D.O., Founder & Lead Psychiatrist at Jeff Ditzell Psychiatry in New York City
What This Means for Your Business
If we can rank a brand-new domain #1 in one of the world’s most competitive markets, we can rank your business.
Most agencies won’t even take new-domain projects in competitive markets. The ones that do charge $50,000-$100,000+ with no guarantees.
We’ve proven we can deliver the impossible—and the rankings we build last.
The Bottom Line
🎯 6 months from brand-new domain to top 10 ranking
💰 $500-$1,000/click keyword value achieved organically
📈 162% increase in website users from search
💼 Practice fully booked from organic traffic within 8 months
⏱️ Rankings still performing months after engagement (proving quality over tricks)
Most “SEO experts” say this is impossible. We made it look routine.
Comments